In his book “Good People, Bad Managers,” Samuel A. Culbert explores the idea that good people can be bad managers. The book delves into the reasons why this happens and provides insights on how to overcome these challenges. The book is divided into four chapters, each focusing on a different aspect of the problem.
In the first chapter, Culbert introduces the concept of the “good person-bad manager” paradox. He explains that many people who are good at their jobs and have a strong moral compass struggle with management. This is because management requires a different set of skills and behaviors than individual contributor roles. Culbert argues that the problem is often exacerbated by the fact that organizations promote good individual contributors into management positions without proper training or preparation.
Chapter 2: The Causes
In the second chapter, Culbert explores the reasons why good people become bad managers. He identifies several factors that contribute to this phenomenon, including the lack of training and preparation for management roles, the pressure to perform and meet targets, and the need to balance competing demands and priorities. Culbert also discusses how the culture of the organization can contribute to the problem, particularly if it values individual achievement over teamwork and collaboration.
Chapter 3: The Solutions
In the third chapter, Culbert provides practical advice for overcoming the challenges of being a good person and a bad manager. He suggests that organizations need to provide better training and development opportunities for managers, particularly in areas such as communication, delegation, and team building. Culbert also emphasizes the importance of creating a supportive and collaborative culture that values teamwork and mutual respect.
Chapter 4: The Consequences
In the final chapter, Culbert discusses the consequences of being a good person and a bad manager. He explains that the stress and frustration of managing can lead to burnout and other negative outcomes for both the manager and their team. Culbert also highlights the impact that bad management can have on employee engagement, morale, and productivity.
Conclusion
Overall, “Good People, Bad Managers” is a thought-provoking book that challenges readers to think differently about management and leadership. Culbert’s insights and advice are relevant for anyone who is struggling with the transition from individual contributor to manager or who is trying to improve their management skills. By highlighting the importance of communication, collaboration, and a supportive culture, Culbert provides a roadmap for building stronger, more effective teams.
Interested in reading the whole book?
Buy the book “Good People, Bad Managers” on Amazon
